A broker said no. Can I try another?
Yes, you can use a different mortgage broker, and for a complex case a second opinion is often sensible. One broker's no is not the whole market: brokers differ in the lenders they can access and in their experience with situations like yours, so another broker may place a case the first could not. Look for whole-of-market access, real experience with your type of case, and clear upfront fees.
Why a second opinion can change the outcome
Not every broker sees the same market. Some are tied or work from a limited panel, so a lender that would accept you may simply not be on their list. Even whole-of-market brokers vary in how comfortable they are with specialist cases: a recent default, a retained-profit director, a portfolio landlord. A broker who places these regularly knows the lender and the way to present the case. That experience, not luck, is often what turns a no into a yes.
What to look for next time
- Whole-of-market or broad-panel access, so the right lender is actually reachable.
- Real experience with your type of case.
- A clear, upfront explanation of any fee and how the broker is paid.
- A willingness to explain why a lender fits, not just to submit and hope.
Common questions
Can I use a different broker after one says no?
Yes. You are not tied to a broker, and getting a second opinion is reasonable, especially for a complex case. Brokers differ in the lenders they can access and in their experience with situations like yours, so another broker may place a case the first could not.
Why would two brokers reach different answers?
Because not all brokers are whole-of-market, and even those that are will have different relationships, experience and confidence with specialist lenders. A broker who rarely handles, say, retained-profit directors or recent defaults may not know the lender who would say yes.
Is it a problem to have been declined already?
A previous decline is worth disclosing so the next broker can work around it, but it does not block a fresh, well-targeted application. What matters is choosing the right lender this time rather than repeating the same approach.
What should I look for in a broker?
Whole-of-market or broad-panel access, genuine experience with your type of case (complex income, adverse credit, buy-to-let), and a clear, upfront explanation of any fees. A regulated mortgage broker can advise you.
See how to choose a mortgage broker.
Founder, MortgageExplained
Adam spent over eight years as a mortgage adviser at Just Mortgages, with further experience in commercial finance. He is CeMAP and CF qualified. He built MortgageExplained to do one thing well: explain mortgages in plain English, so you know where you stand before you speak to a regulated broker. Every page on the site is written by Adam.
Last reviewed: